By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to the use of cookies to ensure that your visit runs smoothly.

Monday, 03 December 2012 17:41

Exploring Gender: Procedural Dramas' Portrayal of Trans* Characters

Written by  Cael

bones

 

Procedural dramas allow audiences into the world of detectives, cops, FBI agents. Some follow a simple formula like CSI, Law and Order, and Cold Case, others are more character-driven like Castle, Bones, and White Collar. How are trans* individuals characterized in this formula?

I tend to prefer the more character-driven dramas. They all focus mainly on the mystery but also provide character development, allowing a look into relationships and motivations. Most of these shows have not really dealt with trans* characters. In season 4, Bones aired “The He in the She.” After finding a victim with a male bone structure, the team discovers her name was Patricia, and she was trans*. Despite having a very insensitive title, Bones went outside of the stereotypes within the episode, respecting the victim’s identity once they discovered the truth. Booth thinks someone murdered her because she was trans*, which would be the stereotypical portrayal of the story, but the motive turns out to be something much more innocuous. This storyline allows a trans* character to be portrayed as simply another person who walked into some bad circumstances.

CSI and Law and Order, on the other hand, have a history of subscribing to stereotypes. It is pretty much certain if you see a foster kid on Law and Order, they are the one who committed the murder. Likewise, trans* characters tend to be the ones to commit the crimes or to die. These shows tend to use trans* individuals to sensationalize their storylines. CSI has more of a record for this than Law and Order, a list of which can be found here as well as a great analysis of CSI’s issues with respecting trans* characters. Of the straight procedurals, Cold Case is the one which has been praised by GLAAD for its portrayal of trans* characters.

What are your impressions of procedural dramas? Are there any episodes featuring trans* characters I should know about? Let me know what you think in the comments, message me here or on tumblr, or email me.

Cael

About

Lezbelib is the online magazine that helps LGBTQ+ women to stay updated with entertaining blogs and breaking news about LGBT rights.