According to ContactMusic, she told him:
"You have no right! Go to another train. Get off this train. Other people believe other things and have every right to believe other things on this planet and in this world."
But the man continued his sermon. So she added:
"As long as you keep talking, I'll keep talking!"
"We do not have to be force-fed this man's religious beliefs. Jesus never said for you to do this - ever!
"Don't come at me because I went to f**king Catholic school for 12 years and I know every line."
A fan sent to TMZ the video of the scene:
Photo credit: Getty Images North America